Christianity & Polyamory
Week 2: Relationship Structures
Two of the foundations of a healthy relationship are (a) clear and productive communication and (b) a clear and shared understanding of relationship agreements.
It’s important to distinguish between descriptive and prescriptive labels when it comes to defining different types of poly relationships. Sometimes folks structure their relationship in a particular way to try to maximize security and minimize vulnerability but this doesn’t necessarily work (and isn’t necessarily the most effective way to achieve those goals). We’ll get into why later.
On the other hand, descriptive labels can be helpful for the folks in the relationship, for friends and family, and for potential new partners to understand what’s going on and what is and is not currently available.
In my work, I see 6 main ways of structuring open or polyamorous relationships. There are of course many more ways to structure or describe your relationship. These are the “big buckets” that are most common.
- Don’t Ask, Don’t Tell
- Sexually Open, Emotionally Monogamous
- Hierarchical
- Veto
- “Kitchen Table Poly”
- Cheating!
Don’t Ask, Don’t Tell
In a Don’t Ask, Don’t Tell open relationship, both partners explicitly agree to have an open sexual and/or emotional relationship and also agree to not tell or ask each other about their outside relationships and activities. The idea is that you should never know that your partner is having these experiences.
The idea is, usually, that thinking about your partner having other relationships or hooking up with other people triggers jealousy or other uncomfortable feelings and so the proposed solution is to try to avoid those feelings by avoiding ever knowing, explicitly, what your partner is up to sexually or romantically.
This model has a few drawbacks though.
It necessitates dishonesty.
If you’re catching up with your boyfriend about what you’ve been up to while he’s out of town on a work trip, you’ll necessarily have to gloss over how you spent some of your time if it involved hooking up. You might say “I spent the night in” which might be technically true, but you could be leaving out that you had someone over.
If your boyfriend asks you do something and you already have plans with a date or hookup, you’ll either have to lie about your reasons for saying no or abruptly cancel your plans.
Another drawback of this approach is that your imagination is almost always scarier than reality.
Your partner could be seeing multiple people every day — or could have seen no one in months or years — and you’d never know the difference. More importantly, you can never know what anything means because you’re not talking about it. It’s easy to fall down a rabbit hole of “my boyfriend is seeing all these people, they’re more attractive than me, the sex is better, he likes than more than me and he’s going to leave me for one of them.” When, if you could just talk with him, you might find out that no matter who he’s seeing or how many people he’s fucking or whether he’s even dating someone — that he still loves you and cares about you and is committed to your relationship.
Folks who have been cheated on often say the deception is equally as painful as the actual act. “I thought I knew this person but it turns out that I don’t.” Don’t Ask, Don’t Tell arrangements scribble out important details in your partner’s life and let your anxious imagination fill in the details.
Plus: this cuts you off from all of the good that can come from open relationships (that’s why you’re doing this after all: to make your life better, fuller. It shouldn’t all be about managing pain). You husband might bring new energy or ideas into your relationship — which will make what you two have even more fulfilling and exciting — but only if you make space for it.
Sexually Open, Emotionally Monogamous
This model of relationship eliminates many of the drawbacks of “Don’t Ask, Don’t Tell” while still attempting to put enough controls on the situation to minimize uncomfortable feelings and get a senes of security and stability.
In this model, you and your partner decide to have a sexually open relationship — and you’re ok talking about those relationships, in fact you may even want to hear about them… whether to help keep your anxiety at bay or because it actively excites. However, you decide that it has to be “just sex” … you can fuck, but you can’t date. Some couples extend this by placing certain restrictions around what’s allowed (for instance “no repeats” or “no sleepovers”)
It’s good that you’re making space to share about your outside experiences … in my experience working with friends & clients, folks find that open communication helps with trust, security, and ultimately fulfillment.
A major drawback to this is that, practically speaking, it rarely works. You can’t decide how you feel about someone. Yes, it’s possible that you and your boyfriend will never develop an emotional or romantic attraction to someone you’re sleeping with … but you can’t guarantee it. You can’t control it. That’s just not how it works. And, often, placing something off-limits only makes it that much more appealing.
So, if you’re going to have a sexually open, emotionally monogamous relationship, you’ll need to figure out what to do when feelings arise. Does the person end it? What if he doesn’t want to? What if he’s in denial about the level of emotions involved? Do you leave him over it then? Thinking through what you’d do if an emotional connection developed (and being intensely honest about your likely reactions) before you move forward is going to make things much easier. Or you might decide another model works better for you.
Hierarchical
In this model of open relationships, some relationships are ranked higher than others. Some folks use labels like “primary partner,” “secondary partner,” and even “tertiary partner.”
For other folks, it’s “the couple” and everyone else… the one boyfriend/husband/partner always comes first, above all others. Everyone else is just a friend, a buddy, a hookup, a friend with benefits, a fling.
There are some real benefits to this model. For one, it’s very clear about who everyone is in your life, what they mean to you, and where they stand. It’s, perhaps, easier to manage expectations when you know that the person you’re dating has a primary partner and only limited time and emotional bandwidth for you. It’s not going to be a surprise if someone turns down your booty call because he’s going to his partner’s law school graduation. It might come as a prize if someone who you think you’re dating cancels a long-planned theater date because his boyfriend has a cold.
However, you can still run into problems. With a hierarchical model of polyamory, the labels are often prescriptive rather than descriptive. You run into trouble when you say “This person is and will always be my primary partner, that person is and can only ever be my secondary partner.”
As we’ve explored with Don’t Ask, Don’t Tell and Sexually Open, Emotionally Monogamous relationship models… humans are complex and sometimes our feelings and desires evolve over time. The random hookup might become a repeat play partner who might become a casual fling who might become someone you have real, deep on-going feelings for. If you’re in a monogamous relationship right now, that might feel scary… “This is why we can’t open up at all! You can’t control it!” you might say. But can you really control your feelings and desires in monogamy? A co-worker can become a happy hour buddy can become an affair can become a divorce. Monogamy claims to offer safety and security, but it’s only an illusion — how many monogamous dating relationships do you know that have ended (a lot!).
Open or poly relationships don’t have to be scary — in fact, they can provide more safety and reassurance. When you’re able to talk openly about your feelings and desires and the various friend and sexual and romantic and somewhere in between relationships that you have, everyone is armed with more information and can make more thoughtful decisions.
If you’re using a hierarchical model of open relationships to try to control those feelings and desires… you may be disappointed. However, if you describe your relationship as hierarchical because that’s how it is currently structured and operating, that can help to give you and your other partners much-needed clarity.
Veto
In a Veto model of open relationship, one (or more) of your partners has the power to “veto” certain aspects of your other relationships — or other people entirely. He might “veto” the date you’ve had planned because he had a bad day at work, or veto your plans to take a weekend trip together because it makes him uncomfortable, or veto you seeing the person at all because he gets a bad vibe.
A Veto model of open relationship is a type of hierarchical relationship in that some partners have veto power over others. You can have this type of relationship in a more polyamorous setup where dating and emotions are involved or in an “open” relationship, where the emphasis is more on sex and hooking up.
This model of open relationship is often used in attempt to protect an existing, core relationship. If anything jeopardizes that — or is thought to jeopardize or might jeopardize that — one of the partners can veto it.
A problem with this approach, though, is what happens in the aftermath of a veto. If you or your boyfriend — or both of you — veto a date or an activity and the other person doesn’t understand why (or otherwise disagrees with your decision), it can be a source of major pain. If this happens repeatedly, it’s easy for bitterness and distrust to build up.
The consequences are even more severe when a person is being vetoed. How would you feel if your boyfriend said that a person you enjoy spending time with and care about is no off limits… you could never see him again. That’s a recipe for a whole lot of heartache. And now you’re faced with the choice: do you aprubtly end this relationship that you don’t want to end? do you openly ignore your partner’s veto? do you see him secretly? then what?
A Veto model is usually intended to protect a relationship, but when a veto is eventually triggered, it often introduces pain, volatility, and insecurity into the relationship.
Negotiated
This way of structuring an open or polyamorous relationship makes room for a number of different sub-types such as “nonhierarchical poly,” “relationship anarchy,” or “solo poly.” You can use this model for polyamory or for an open relationship where there is still a core couple or where you’re looking for more casual encounters.
This model emphasizes boundaries and agreements rather than rules and rigid structures. It’s based on open communication, consent, and trust rather than control.
In a negotiated open relationship, each partner gets clear on what he’s looking for and, importantly, what his boundaries are. From there, you work together to find ways of relating with the goal being that everyone wins, everyone feels good. Not that there won’t be some growing pains along the way, not that you’re never feel uncomfortable, but rather that you’re working together toward a common, consensual goal, rather than begrudgingly making trade-offs.
Some examples of boundaries, agreements, and requests are:
- “For me to feel safe in my own home, it’s important to me know if someone else will be in my house”
- “I will only have condomless sex with someone if they are not having condomless sex with other people (or they’re doing it with people who I am also not using condoms with)”
- “I’m always excited to hear about your dates or hookups, but you’re never obligated to tell me”
- “We have a standing date night every Tuesday and will respect each other’s time by giving as much notice as we can if we want or need to cancel or reschedule”
In this model, you don’t try to box in emotions or setup rules that are then asking to be broken. Instead of setting yourself up for conflict, you set yourself up for communication and collaboration. You share what you’re up to, what you’re feeling and needing, and what your hopes, desires, frustrations, and anxieties are.
This requires time, attention, and effort. You will probably be uncomfortable at times. But, in my experience and the experience of my friends and folks I’ve worked with, this model leads to less stress overall and a greater sense of commitment and shared purpose — because you’re working together rather than policing each other’s thoughts and actions.
Inside the course & community, there will be lessons on identifying your needs, working through feelings, setting boundaries, and making productive agreements where we really get into the nitty gritty of it.
Cheating
When talking about open relationships, folks rarely bring up cheating but I think it’s important to mention it. If you’re in a monogamous relationship and one of you cheats on the other: it’s no longer monogamous, even if you don’t know it (yet). The difference between this model and the others is that those are consensual and mutually agreed upon, cheating is nonconsensual and unethical.
If you or your partner wants an ethical, consensual open relationship, that’s a sign that you or he DOESN’T want to cheat. And that’s a good thing.
Infidelity happens so frequently that most of us accept it as a fact of life — to other people, if not ourselves — even while we don’t approve of it.
I definitely don’t think you should cheat on your partner but I do want to try to understand where that impulse comes from. There’s all sorts of reasons why people cheat and “I don’t value my partner” or “I don’t want to be in this relationship” is often not one of them.
(If infidelity is part of your relationship journey, you may benefit from The State of Affairs by Ester Perel)
So, if we can recognize that nonmonogamy is already a thing that’s happening in many relationships that we think are monogamous, then we can work toward a healthy, consensual, ethical nonmonogamy which adds fulfillment to your life, rather than pain.
Back to Dashboard